• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About and Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Civil Candor

political cynicism for turbulent times

  • American Values
  • Big Government
  • Government Ethics
  • Immigration

Helping the Poor: the Political Issue That Will Hurt You

February 20, 2014 by Bob Prokop 2 Comments

Helping the poor would be a good thing if we could do it right. Demands to do it wrong makes helping the poor the most dangerous political issue of this election year. It will hurt us not because we are afraid to take a stand against throwing money at poverty, but because we won’t voice outrage at an agenda determined to use the bottom to control the top. Pandering to poverty keeps public officials in power and for some that makes it a good thing.

What does helping the poor really mean?

There are few better appeals for overspending than helping the poor. That’s why income inequality is a political issue that serves the party’s interests best when it is debated but never solved.

Does helping the poor mean empowering those who contribute the least to decide where our money is spent? Is it political correctness or misplaced decency that prevents us from admitting that those who contribute the most should be the ones making the decisions? Liberal Democrats will protest, but without the struggle over tax dollars they would have no platform and no party.

The chair of the Congressional Black Caucus recently threw down the gauntlet, insinuating that Democrats and the disadvantaged should be in the driver’s seat:

This is simply egregious.

We cannot continue to believe that a growing economy guarantees higher wages and income for all. Because it does not.1

A growing economy guarantees nothing, but it expands opportunity and gives everyone a better chance. A stumbling economy hits the bottom hardest. Even Democrats and their president figured that one out, though they come up short on accepting responsibility. That’s where taxpayers’ wallets come in.

Does helping the poor mean government sets the standard of living?

Do minimum wage workers want the government to determine what their standard of living should be? $10.10 an hour is not going to put anyone at the gate to Middle America, but that’s not what Democrats are preaching:

In order to help the working poor and middle class, we must raise the minimum wage; invest in education; improve our infrastructure; reign in Wall Street and return our focus to Main Street.2

The right and left both had a field day with the CBO’s take on the effects of a higher guaranteed income. Neither side took offense at the government mandating the standard of living that constitutes helping the poor.

The private sector has a pretty good track record for rewarding talent and striking back when big government interferes with free enterprise. This is the time to strike back. In lieu of more tax increases for social spending, Democrats have turned compensation into a contentious political issue by trying to force businesses to pay workers without marketable skills more than what the market deems they are worth.

Is it the duty of employers to top off paychecks with a welfare payment? That is a political issue we will beat to death well before midterms arrive. What we know for a fact is that $10.10 an hour will only whet the Democratic Party’s appetite for extorting more money from the middle and the top to fund the same old spending vehicles that didn’t work before and won’t work now.

The real political issue is who pays for Democrats.

Citizens United is still a thorn in the paw of politicians worried that they can’t spend more than corporations. Their solution is to try to extract campaign contributions from constituents who don’t have a lot of money and should be spending what they have on other things. H.R. 20, the Government by the People Act, offers a tax credit for small political contributions. The bill also establishes a Freedom from Influence Fund to match these small dollar donations. Since money, where it goes, and who begs loud enough for a cut are the political issues that matter most to politicians, the trick is to dupe naïve voters into donating by waving the flag:

“Whether it’s jobs, education, health care or the environment, big money politics warps Congress’s priorities and erodes the public’s trust in government,” said Congressman Sarbanes. “We need a government of, by and for the people – not bought and paid for by big money donors and special interests.”3

Perhaps we should add political contributions to the list of items you can buy with food stamps. Would that help politicians eradicate hunger in America?

Alas, there is no Mother Theresa in Washington. Helping the poor is only a noble pursuit in the absence of ulterior motives. The question for Americans is how badly do we want to get hurt? How much debt should we run up for failed endeavors that help politicians more than their poverty-stricken poster children?

H.R. 2182, the Half in Ten Act of 2013, argued that one of the benefits of helping the poor and reducing poverty is to bring in more tax revenue. That’s the kind of honesty we need from Washington. The real political issue isn’t helping Americans out of poverty. It is helping Democrats help themselves.

Sources

Updated June 11, 2016: links revised.

Filed Under: American Values Tagged With: Democrats, midterm elections

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Helen says

    February 21, 2014 at 4:29 pm

    History has shown that there will always be poor, some for no fault of there own, some for being intellectually handicapped, some who feel the government owes them a living. Raising the minimum wage will cost jobs since many employers will not pay it. Constantly expecting the taxpayer to bail out the poor only keeps the Democrats in power. We need the government to work to create job opportunities and to expect that everyone who is capable of working, is working.

    Reply
    • Bob says

      February 21, 2014 at 6:58 pm

      Democrats have made that last item a bit of a problem, too. Who else would try to put a positive spin on people quitting their jobs because they no longer need employer-sponsored health insurance?

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

DON’T MISS

Trump addressing joint session of Congress March 4, 2025.

Disappearing People Solves Our Disappearing Illegals Problem

April 21, 2025 By Bob Prokop

F-22 Raptor that shot down Chinese spy balloon. Jim Garamond. U.S. Dept. of Defense.

10 Political Hypocrisy Examples to Make You Even Angrier

April 3, 2025 By Bob Prokop

Bullying By Proxy Is Dangerous Public Policy

May 3, 2025 By Bob Prokop

George Washington

Good People Deserve Goodness from Government

March 24, 2025 By Bob Prokop

Nazi pennant. 1945. Eisenhower National Historic Site, courtesy NPS.

Hitler’s Advice to Democrats: We the People are Dumb

February 26, 2025 By Bob Prokop

Sow during her piglets. Photo courtesy USDA ARS.

Democrats Hate Limited Government for One Simple Reason

February 9, 2025 By Bob Prokop

White House with rainbow colors. White House photo by Chuck Kennedy.

American Values Don’t Exist. Trump Just Proved It.

February 6, 2025 By Bob Prokop

Solitary tree with no leaves standing in a field

Politics Will End Humanity. Our Leaders are the Reason.

January 19, 2025 By Bob Prokop

Crash graphic from "NTSB Calls for Alcohol Detection Systems in All New Vehicles."

Hit and Run Biden Leaves the Scene: Never Forget Who We Lost

January 1, 2025 By Bob Prokop

President Biden delivers Continued Battle for the Soul of the Nation address. White House photo by Adam Schultz.

Fascism is Democratic Party Policy. They Call it Democracy.

November 11, 2024 By Bob Prokop

Soldier laying flags at Arlington Cemetery. (U.S. Army photo by Elizabeth Fraser / Arlington National Cemetery/released)

Being American is Hard. The Left is Too Lazy for the Challenge.

September 10, 2024 By Bob Prokop

Recent and Relevant

  • Bullying By Proxy Is Dangerous Public Policy
  • Disappearing People Solves Our Disappearing Illegals Problem
  • 10 Political Hypocrisy Examples to Make You Even Angrier
  • Good People Deserve Goodness from Government
  • Hitler’s Advice to Democrats: We the People are Dumb

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in