Civil Candor

political cynicism for turbulent times

Copyright © 2019 CivilCandor.com

Home » Economy » Mr. Cameron, Would You Like A Job?

Mr. Cameron, Would You Like A Job?

Last update December 9, 20171 Comment

When the UK’s Prime Minister has had his fill of being pilloried for the budget cuts announced last week, we should offer him a job. This country needs someone with the courage to do more than shift priorities to give the appearance of cutting spending.

Our $1.3 trillion deficit, at only 8.9% of GDP, is a meager effort. Ireland boasts a deficit that is a stunning 32% of GDP. Americans are competitive, though, and if we are patient and focus on spending, we still have a chance to best the Emerald Isle. Our public debt could hit 69% of GDP by 2020 [1], so there is still hope for victory.

Federal agencies less self-interested than our Legislative and Executive Branches have warned about out of control spending for decades. We were cautioned in 1977, when the deficit was confined to two digits:

Under the less optimistic assumption about nonfederal demand, the federal deficit would still be sizeable by 1982 — approximately $72 billion. [2]

We were warned in 1984, when the billions required three digits:

Under current policies, the Congressional Budget Office projects very large and growing deficits, rising from nearly $200 billion in 1985 to over $300 billion in 1989. [3]

We passed the 1990 Budget Enforcement Act after Gramm-Rudman-Hollings failed, but the BEA did not work, either:

Nonetheless, the deficit did not come down to the levels promised in 1990. When the BEA was enacted, policymakers believed that the deficit would be lowered substantially, but the BEA included no requirement for additional deficit reduction if this outlook worsened. [4]

We now have a deficit that could balloon to $6.2 trillion over the next ten years. [5] Fortunately, with the deficit growing so rapidly, spending bills like the $50 billion infrastructure bank proposed by President Obama no longer have a cost:

This plan will be fully paid for.  It will not add to our deficit over time.  And we are going to work with Congress to see to that. [6]

Anticipating a 2010 election recovery, Republican leaders broached a potential $100 billion in budget cuts. Their language is bold, but the details are hazy. Stating that “spending cuts can happen” [7] is much easier than making those cuts a reality. The Pledge to America calls for a federal hiring freeze, which calls the GOP’s dedication into question. Why stop there?

Nearly thirty years ago, we were warned about the cost of civil service benefits:

Civil service retirement benefits are much greater than those typically available in the private sector. From this point of view, the costs to government of the current CSR system are excessive. [8]

Decades later, as recession forced the private sector to cut salaries and jobs, Washington followed the lead of the banks and passed out raises, including a 3.9% increase for federal pay systems in 2009, and a 2.0% bump in 2010.

Government takes care of its own, so state and local governments unable to pay their employees were given federal money to guarantee incomes. We paid $26 billion to save 300,000 state and local public sector jobs, which mollified labor unions that backed the show of federal solicitude, just in time for the midterm elections (see: No Money To Pay Teachers, Police, Firefighters, and Nurses? Fire Them.).

To ensure that those no longer working for government still enjoyed a raise, retirees in the Civil Service Retirement System received a 4.1% increase in January 2006, a 3.3% increase in January 2007, and a whopping 5.8% increase in January 2009. [9] Less fortunate Federal Employee Retirement System beneficiaries received only a 4.8% bump in January 2009. [10] Taxpayers who paid for these benefits lost their jobs and their savings, and watched their possessions being carried out to the curb alongside the trash.

Cutting public sector pay and benefits would be a historic accomplishment, and would demonstrate our resolve to cut spending, no matter what. A Washington so ethically bankrupt that it uses money collected from unemployed taxpayers during a recession to overly enrich its own personnel deserves to have its budget reduced to the barest essentials. If anyone in Washington, or hoping to prevail on Tuesday, has the courage to do this, the time to speak up is now. We have heard some noise, but what we need is resolve after the election is over. If Mr. Cameron is available, maybe he can help us with that.

1...Congressional Budget Office. The Budget and Economic Outlook: An Update. August 2010. p. ix.

2...Congressional Budget Office. Update to Five-Year Budget Projections: Fiscal Years 1978-1982. July 1977. p. 5.

3...Statement of Rudolph G. Penner, Director, Congressional Budget Office before the Committee on Appropriations. United States Senate. February 22, 1984. p. 2.
4...Congressional Budget Office. Reducing the Deficit: Spending and Revenue Options. March 1994. p. 6.

5...Congressional Budget Office. The Budget and Economic Outlook: An Update. August 2010. p. ix.

6...Remarks by the President on Rebuilding America’s Infrastructure. October 11, 2010.

7...John Boehner. Press Office. Yes, We Can Cut Spending: UK Leads the Way in Slashing Bloated Government. October 20, 2010.

8...Congressional Budget Office. Statement of Earl A. Armbrust, Deputy Assistant Director for General Government Management fore the Committee of the Budget. U.S. House of Representatives. March 12, 1981.

9...U.S. Office of Personnel Management. List of Cost-of-Living Adjustments (COLA).

10..Ibid.

Filed Under: Economy Tagged With: midterm elections, recession

Comments

  1. Andrew says

    October 29, 2010 at 2:09 pm

    The country is broke, many citizens have lost their jobs and homes. Food pantries are trying to help hundreds more families than ever before. The government is oblivious to what is going on in the towns and cities across the United States. Obama and Congress keep on handing out money as if there is no end to the supply. They just find something else to tax. At some point, Obama and Congress are going to have to stop. No way can we keep this up. The first place to start would be cutting all federal, state and local government salaries and perks to the level of the private sector. Why are we giving so much aid to illegal immigrants when our own citizens are going without and why should illegals get free medical? All at the taxpayers’ expense. Union employees wages are way above the private sector, yet they are always asking and getting more. Why should they be paid at a higher level? This would be a good place to cut. It is time to stop and think about what we are doing to the current and future generations of this country.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Apotheosis of Washington. Architect of the Capitol.

Apotheosis of Washington
Architect of the Capitol

BROWSE

Civil Candor uses cookies. To help you decide if this is acceptable please read our Privacy Policy